Some Notes Towards A Meta-epistemological Manifesto

I had an epiphany today.

I have always mistrusted the concept of genre.  It has seemed to me to be both a hobble and a crutch.  By which I mean that by accepting a specific genre designation an author restricted her or his writing to an abbreviated range, while at the same time adjuring readers to carry the story past certain difficulties by imposing on an unearned suspension of disbelief.

This did not seem to be a good bargain to me–from either side.

Today it occurred to me that this unnatural division of stories into either this thing or that thing but never both at once mirrors the description that G K Chesterton gives of post-Christian philosophies in his book Orthodoxy.

Chesterton says it much more eloquently that I am about to (which is why I supplied you with the link) but in essence his thesis is that Christianity represents virtues in opposition and in balance. Charity is balanced by Justice, for example, neither subservient to the other, not mixing into some sort of compromise where only reasonable sins can be forgiven and only reasonable debts need be paid, but both burning fiercely and both necessary.  “Love the sinner and hate the sin,” is the Christian formula.

Chesterton goes on to say that both Charity and Justice, though good in themselves, can give rise to evil when separated. Charity that loves the sin ceases to be charitable, and is merely indulgent, while Justice that hates the sinner ceases to be just and becomes simple vengeance.

Adopting this schemata for a more humble and profane use, I can see Art, too, as a matter of virtues in opposition. In particular fiction should not, as is currently surmised, be either fantastic or reasonable, but must strive for both fantasy and reason.

What is more, the nascent literary movement called “Pulp Revival” is, in my opinion, a reformation that strives to return to a time when Art–at least the best of it–did balance on this tension of reason and fantasy. “This is the edge of the wild,” said the writers of the Weird Tales, “beyond this point abide monsters.” Implicit in that statement, however, was that it was also the edge of the tame, the reasonable, the sane. One cannot have monsters without heroes to oppose them, else they are not monstrous, but mundane.

And that gives me grounds to understand what I had always felt–that the classification of fiction gives rise to virtues in isolation.  Horror says, “Here you must have courage,” and Romance says, “Here you may feel tenderness”, but courage without tenderness is bravado and tenderness without courage becomes sentimentality. Virtue in isolation must walk softly or risk knocking down the edifice of story, but in company Virtues are free to run wild, the excesses of one moderated by the excesses of another.

In particular the division of Science Fiction from Fantasy has always bothered me.  One must have either a world of rules or a world of magic, but not both.  Determinism or Existentialism.  There was no such division in the Weird Tale, and there was neither Determinism nor Existentialism.

Instead there was the sense of Order Interrupted. The Universe does and should make sense, but it does not do so of its own accord.  Instead, it must made to be reasonable, it must be mastered. The heroes of a Weird Tale may fail in their efforts to impose Order onto Chaos, but that effort must be both necessary and laudable. One does not surrender to the unknown, if we go down, we go down fighting, secure in the knowledge that striking a single match in the darkness may be doomed, but never futile.

And thus will I end these notes–towards, as I said, but not yet in sight of my goal.

 

Posted in Artists That I Admire, On Writing, Poetry, Who I am | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 7 Comments

A Hill of Stars, By Misha Burnett

Cirsova magazine now has my short story from Issue #1 up on the website.

Source: A Hill of Stars, By Misha Burnett

Posted in Artists That I Admire, On Publishing, On Writing | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

My Review of Roger Zelazny’s “Lord Of Light”

New review up on The Castalia House Blog.  Roger Zelazny’s Lord Of Light

Posted in Artists That I Admire, On Writing, Poetry | Tagged , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

14

Mr. Mephistopheles, dressed in red
Wrote a letter to The Times
He considered carefully what he said
And mailed it with two shiny dimes

Miss Antigone, pretty young thing
Hung herself on the telegraph wire
For seven days they let her swing
Then cut her down and put her on the fire

Ham-fisted Jake played with a snake
Onsies, twosies, never let go
Until it bit him by mistake
When that happened he died slow

Mr. Mephistopheles put down his pen
Went to bed woke up and then

Posted in On Writing, Poetry, Who I am | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

13

Everybody walks in the Kingdom of the Ants
Everybody dances on Butterfly Hill
Turn around bend down pull up your pants
Run as fast as you can and now stand still

Nobody wants to be the last in line
Turn around spread your legs reach for the skies
Everybody wants to think that everything is fine
Nobody wants to die and everybody dies

Somebody wants to dance in a square
Anybody wants to dance in a line
Turn around turn around gasping for air
Everybody wants to think that everything is fine

Everyone dances until everyone gets hurt
Turn around close your eyes lie down in the dirt

Posted in On Writing, Poetry, Who I am | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

12

Look to the skies, the monsters cried loud
A warning will come from the sky
We waited for fire to fall from a cloud
Certain that we would soon die

Time is short, the end is near
The monsters cried out once more
We huddled together numb with fear
Sure that death stood at the door

This is it, the monsters announced
This time we mean it for sure
Rains of blood and dragons that pounced
Diseases that don’t have a cure

Yet here we still are, and have been for so long
I’m beginning to think that the monsters are wrong.

Posted in On Writing, Poetry, Who I am | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

11

Where have all the children gone, marching off to peace
Singing songs and waving flags and crying up the heaven
Praying to their inner gods that fighting all would cease
Shouting to the world with the sound turned to eleven

Children pushing children, children rolling tires
Breaking things and making messes all around the town
Children stealing candy, children lighting fires
Wanting to play games and turn things upside down

Where have all the grownups gone, who let the children play
School is out and all the babysitters fled
Children who do nothing except run around all day
Running with scissors until some of them are dead

They say that they love children, but I doubt
If they loved them they wouldn’t throw them out

Posted in On Writing, Poetry, Who I am | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment